The Irritability of Medium Things
I hate thinking of titles for manuscripts. I'm terrible at it! When I'm working on a project, I generally refer to it in my notes as "So-and-So's story" or by something that figures into the plot, such as "goats!"
Eventually a phrase from the text pops out that encapsulates the story for me, and I go with it as a title. But that doesn't mean it speaks to anyone but me. It might be bland. Or obscure. Or boring-sounding. And I have to go back to the drawing board.
(Understand that I only obsess about this stuff after all the heavy lifting is done—when I've revised as much as I can revise and I'm about to send it out into the world.)
Anyway, when my latest manuscript's working title was deemed non-grabby (true, alas), I did lots of brainstorming and came up with dozens of titles that were even worse than the first one! I also futilely Googled for novel-naming advice—futilely because there's no magic Book-Naming Fairy that lives on the Internet and just tells you what to name your book.
I did turn up a few fun/interesting sites worth sharing, though:
- Naming Your Baby: How to Choose a Selling Title - Straightforward advice and techniques for brainstorming and choosing a title for your fiction or nonfiction book.
- What's in a Name? Titles for Your Novel - This article is tailored to fantasy novels, but the various techniques can be easily adapted to any genre.
- Title Your Novel in Three Easy Steps! or, The Abstraction of Abstraction - Why not name your novel something completely vague and abstract? Everyone else is doing it! (I owe this one a chuckle and the title to this post.)
- Lulu Title Scorer - This "scientific" web toy will predict the probability of your novel becoming a bestseller, based on its title alone!
As for my manuscript—well, I did think of a new title eventually. Unfortunately, I can't swear it's any better than the old one. But according to the Lulu Title Scorer, it has a 79.6% chance of being a bestselling title! (The old one? A lowly 55.4.)


i can relate--i'm terrible at thinking up song titles (except in the case of songs where i repeat the same phrase 100 times--hello, "kindergarten boyfriend"). and do you remember the year we met doing nanowrimo, when my protagonist got thru close to 30k words without a name? yeah.
"Kindergarten Boyfriend" will be stuck in my head for the rest of the day, thankyouverymuch. :-) It did occur to me that I'm grateful I don't have to think of a title for every chapter/song/poem/other short thing. Once every 50,000 words I should be able to handle. You might think.
Also: poor "Prot"!
Also: according to the Lulu TitleScorer your upcoming memoir Kindergarten Boyfriend has a 41.4% chance of becoming a bestsller!